I've owned this for about a month and took it through its paces. The amps sound great, but they do need tweaking. Learning to EQ will be essential with this unit if you're using it as an amp modeler.
The cabs are likewise very good, although it's possible to import your own IR's and possibly save yourself from having to tweak lots of parameters (unless you like that).
The effects are perfect. It's not even a question of sounding good or great or whatever, they're just perfect. You'll find pretty much any effect you're looking for, it'll pretty much sound good right away, while still also giving you the option to tweak all kinds of parameters if you want to. There are multiple places in the signal path to regulate volume level (adequately expressed in +/- db, not that 0 to 100 nonsense you find all too often) so maintaining unity gain is no problem at all. I still prefer to use my analogue overdrives, but I could absolutely use the ones in the Stomp (and I do for snapshots). It's a small difference.
Dual paths are very nice for combining effects. I especially like having the option to trigger the secondary path only over/under a certain frequency or dynamic range. For example it's allowed me to create a preset where the bass notes (strings 5 and 6) are doubled by an octaver while the high notes (roughly strings 4 through 1) are not.
It's made many of my other effects redundant. For example I love my Boss DD-8 delay, but I pretty much stopped using it, and am considering selling it because the delays on the Stomp are equally good if not better, and easy to use and integrate in snapshots. If you don't know what snapshots are, watch a video demonstration. They're brilliant.
I want to explain why I have rated it 3/5 on handling:
I wish to give an unbiased review and point out the weaknesses of this unit:
- the UI does take some learning. Once learned, it is quick and intuitive, allowing you to make presets on the unit in minutes. However it'll take some actual studying to get you there. Also, it does show its age when compared to something like the UI of the Quad Cortex or the new Helix Stadium. It's not tragic, but it might be a turn off for some.
- It is possible to run out of blocks or dsp. Not often, and if you're using it alongside other pedal it won't be a problem 95/100 times. However it can happen and you just have to live with it when it does.
- The looper is there, and that's all the good I can say about it. It has a short recording time (I belive 45 seconds but I could be wrong), it uses up an effects block and it is cumbersome to actually assign footswitches to it. Since you only have three footswitches on the unit anyway, I don't recommend it. You'll definitely still need a separate looper if you loop heavily or even moderately.
- the factory presets are not good. I recommend ditching them as soon as you get the unit, and creating your own.
Obviously this is time intensive and thus the stomp won't sound great out of the box. It'll however sound better and better and better the more time you put into it. Once you've built your collection of presets, you'll have all your sounds ready to follow you everywhere.
It's a fantastic unit and I wholeheartedly recommend it