Acoustic piano VS Digital piano – What’s better?

Acoustic piano VS Digital piano – What’s better?

After the first rush of emotion is over, you realize: The piano is a sensationally versatile instrument that is at home in any musical style and on which you can express any musical idea. Whether you play classical music, jazz or pop, by sight or by ear, whether you compose yourself or play other people’s songs, the piano gives you the full range of musical expression. The piano has a range that is in no way inferior to that of a symphony orchestra and can change from the most delicate pianissimo to the thundering fortissimo within fractions of a second. It is the instrument of choice for most composers and not without reason: you can do almost anything on it and – a bonus especially for beginners – all notes are neatly lined up on the keyboard and can be called up at the push of a button, so to speak. ?❤


Acoustic piano or digital piano – what is better?

To erase all prejudices from the get-go: Modern digital pianos are so good that you can learn to play the piano just as well as on a traditional acoustic instrument. If you disagree, chances are that you last studied the subject about 15 years ago and therefore have no idea. The days when digital pianos sounded artificial and had rattling keyboards are fortunately over, unless you choose the cheapest model. Nevertheless, the classic acoustic variant is by no means obsolete. What are the advantages and disadvantages of both options?

A piano or grand piano is an acoustic instrument that vibrates and resonates, giving you a more direct feeling for the sound than a digital piano. Unfortunately, this is also one of the disadvantages: You can’t turn an acoustic piano down. The vibrations propagate through floors and walls, which in rented flats can be a nuisance for the grumpy neighbour with the broomstick, especially when you are devoting yourself to your new passion at night. If you want to play the piano acoustically, you should have the right premises (or a good lawyer). Tip: Some manufacturers offer acoustic instruments with a silent system, such as Yamaha and Kawai (see pianos 4 and 5 below ?).

Another, quite “heavy” disadvantage becomes apparent when you are about to move – even if it’s only from one room to another: you can’t really get anywhere without the help of specialized and expensive piano movers. And of course you have to tune acoustic instruments regularly – recurring costs that should not be underestimated. A clear advantage of acoustic pianos and grand pianos, however, is that, although high-quality instruments are a costly investment, they retain their value very well and are often inherited over many generations. You have “something for life”, and in the best case not just for one.


What are the advantages of digital pianos?

Digital pianos, which are available in many sizes, designs and price ranges, have their great strengths exactly where the weaknesses of the acoustic representatives lie: they are more compact, lighter, often much cheaper and – probably the biggest advantages in daily life – you don’t have to tune them and can simply turn their volume down or even practice on them with headphones. There are digital pianos that, like acoustic pianos, are stately “musical furniture” for the living room at home – even some digital grand pianos are available. If you don’t have much space or want to transport the instrument occasionally, you can choose a compact digital piano that is much lighter and space-saving. Here the transition to stage pianos is smooth, although the latter often have no built-in loudspeakers – they are connected to an amplification system, on stage anyway – and are therefore less suitable for practising at home.

Digital pianos have undergone a remarkable development in the quality of keyboards, sounds and speaker systems. Sophisticated keyboard mechanics, elaborately sampled sounds and powerful loudspeakers make sure that you really have to listen three times to hear middle and upper class instruments in order to notice the difference to an acoustic instrument. But also inexpensive digital pianos like the Hemingway DP501 WH, which is also available as a set with a piano bench and headphones, or the somewhat better equipped Hemingway DP701 MKII don’t have to hide these days and offer a very good introduction to piano playing.


Where can I learn to play the piano?

Your passion has been ignited and you’ve made it: your new piano, whether analog or digital, is at home with you. Now all you need is a master who will introduce you to the secrets of finger playing using every trick in the book. One possibility is for you to look for a good piano teacher offline who suits you and with whom you are on the same wavelength. The advantage of face-to-face lessons: the teacher is able to respond to your personal preferences and you get immediate feedback. The disadvantage: Without a regular appointment it is not possible. The lessons take place at fixed times (which can also have its advantages!).

Or you can opt for an online piano school. In the meantime there are many high-quality offers on the Internet such as music2me, which are didactically well thought out and technically elaborately implemented with video instructions. The advantages: You can practice when and where you want, and it is much cheaper than with a human teacher. The disadvantages: Despite all progress in the field of artificial intelligence, the personal component is missing. 


Advice

If you have any questions or consulting requests, please feel free to contact us, that’s what we’re here for. We advise you without obligation.

Contact for digital and acoustic pianos:

Piano gallery
klaviere@thomann.de
Phone: 09546-9223-34

Head of Stage pianos division:
Studio / Synth / Computer
studio@thomann.de
Phone: 09546-9223-30

Author’s gravatar
Joe has been singing since he can remember and started playing guitar when he was 10. He's been using it as a songwriting tool ever since. He is passionate about melody and harmony and admires musicians who create these in unique ways. Check out his alternative / indie projects Best of Feelings and Zef Raček.

3 comments

    Great information, and detail.private piano tutors can be an advantage,as the tutor can respond to your skills,styles, and confidence with the piano keyboard.ken rob

    Very informative many thanks.
    My problem is with Yamaha digital piano (big name). I have been playing digi pianos for the last 30 or more years. First one,”Technics”a fantastic digi piano(3), sadly not made now.Since then Yamaha (4).I traded up a 709 two months ago for a CVP 809 and within 2weeks it gave up the ghost! Yamaha have given me a replacement but 2or3 notes on this one have no sustain,
    and there is a dynamics effect which isn’t working either. All in all I’m pretty well fed up with the sound quality and for an instrument that costs £9000 need l say more!? I’d appreciate your comments.
    Sincerely

    Incredibly informative post on violin costs. Though expensive, good violins are built to last. Having one over a lifetime certainly makes use of the heavy upfront costs. That’s why Teds-list believes it is especially important to purchase the necessary accessories to keep new violins in optimal playing shape. If you would like to find out our personal recommendations please head over to our post on the violin.

    Thank you for reading.

    Mo

Leave a Reply

ADVERTISEMENT